3 Great Pizza Joints to Get Pizza on Amelia Island

Admire the grandness of Amelia island history, from its stunning beach sides to its authentic Old Florida historic district. Amelia Island history is at every turn, making it one of the top destinations in Florida.

But all of this amounts to very little if, at the end of the day, you can’t get a good slice of pizza. Fortunately, you are in luck. Below we covered our top three favorite Amelia island pizza joints to hang out and enjoy the atmosphere. Whether you fold your pizza in half or cut it into intricately small squares with a knife and fork, there’s a spot for you.

Shrimp pizza at Townies Pizzeria in Fernandina Beach

Townies Pizzeria

Townies Pizzeria is an unabashed straight-to-the-point pizza joint. There’s real cheese, fresh dough made daily, and homemade sauces. Townies comes right out of New York City, with pizza crafted from true Italian home recipes.

There’s a sense of community the moment you step into Townies. This plays out in the atmosphere and camaraderie, but also in how the pizza joint supports Amelia Island. The team helps host events and fundraisers monthly to support local initiatives and organizations. Townies is a fantastic place to get a good idea of the community’s big heart for social change and good. This has allowed Townies to be an invaluable site for the community.

Townies offers delivery to any of the local vacation rentals in Fernandina Beach. If you do want to go to the pizzeria, it is located about a mile south of the main historic downtown area of Fernandina Beach. Parking and transportation in Fernandina Beach is not difficult, but it is especially easy here. Townies has its own parking lot.

Pizza from Pi Infinite Combinations in Fernandina Beach

Pi Infinite Combinations

Come into Pi Infinite Combinations to make an epic and unique concoction of whole milk mozzarella cheese, sauce, and fresh ingredients topped on the freshly made dough.

Pi Infinite Combinations is most well-known for its gourmet pies. There are four main menu pizzas to select from. The Pulled Prok BBQ Pi with sweet peppers and dill pickle chips is a delightful addition, matched alongside the Brie and Prosciutto Pi, topped with ruby red grapes and house grown rosemary.

The real winner may be the Curry, Goat Cheese, and Shrimp Pi, with splashes of curry oil and arugula. These pizzas help innovative the basic foundation of a good pizza. They are creations of an excellent team of inventive pizza lovers who seek to amplify the pizza-eating experience. Guests can start with an appetizer, like the Cheese Garlic Bread Steaks, move onto a custom-crafted pizza, and close the meal out with a Vanilla Raspberry Samie or a Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream Sandwich.

The highlight of the restaurant is the glorious foliage-filled outdoor seating. Take a seat by the cobblestone and let the pleasant flow of the fountain water set the ambiance.

Pi Infinite is located at 19 S 3rd St. in historic Fernandina Beach. It is open from 12 p.m. to 2 p.m. and then again from 4 p.m. to 8 p.m. (9 p.m. Friday and Saturday).

Woodfire pizza in Fernandina Beach

Arte Pizza

Arte Woodfire Pizza and grill best captures authentic Napoli-styled pizza on Amelia Island. Every slice embodies that thick, smoky taste you crave. With options like the sausage, onions and spicy cherry peppers-coated Calabresa and the eggplant, feta cheese, mushrooms covered Vegetariana, there’s a special concoction for every type of pizza lover. Visitors can also indulge in the Everything option- a madhouse mix of your top five favorite toppings, with choice of cheese and crust (regular or gluten-free).

Arte Pizza also has calzones and artisan made meals, like the Eggplant Parmigiana and the Woodfire Baked Ziti. Arte is a warm semi-casual eatery, in the downtown historic Fernandina Beach. It is right up against the Amelia River, located at 109 N 3rd St. The restaurant has varying hours, but you can usually find it open from 4 p.m. to 9:30 p.m., with extended afternoon hours on Saturday and Sunday.

Don’t forget to explore our available Amelia Island condos for a waterfront place to stay. Allow us to host your whole group for your next Amelia Island escape.