Nestled in the heart of Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach is a charming coastal town with a rich historical heritage and a vibrant culinary scene. Known for its pristine beaches and welcoming atmosphere, Fernandina Beach is a prime destination for those seeking a delightful mix of relaxation and adventure.
Among its many offerings, Fernandina Beach seafood restaurants stand out as some of the best, delivering exquisite dishes that perfectly capture the essence of coastal cuisine. When you’re staying in our Amelia Island vacation rentals these Fernandina Beach restaurants are sure to elevate your dining experience.
Salty Pelican Bar and Grill
The Salty Pelican Bar and Grill is a standout among seafood restaurants in Fernandina Beach, Florida, offering an incredible combination of great food, an exciting location, and a fun atmosphere. The owners set out on a mission to create a dining experience that delivers high-quality, consistent food and beverages through friendly and genuine service. Located at a picturesque spot, their mission has truly been realized. Enjoy seafood classics including crab cakes and oysters by the dozen, or try something a little different like their seafood pot pie. For a taste of their culinary expertise, try the Beer Braised Short Rib, served with garlic smashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables, house-made beef gravy, fried onion straws, and fried jalapenos. Pair this mouthwatering dish with a glass of Bonanza Cabernet Sauvignon for an unforgettable meal.
Salt Life Food Shack

Salt Life Food Shack is another highlight in Fernandina Beach with its expansive outdoor seating area, roof-top bar, lounge, and shaded patio. You can also choose to cool off indoors and admire their custom-built saltwater aquarium featured on Tanked. Guests love the laid-back vibes, friendly staff, and eclectic menu. Start off with the Shrimp and Chorizo Nachos, topped with corn, black beans, jack and cheddar cheese, pico, and finished with a cilantro lime cream drizzle. For your entree, try the Seared Mahi Bowl, featuring miso-marinated mahi seared and served over sticky rice with sautéed spinach, squash, zucchini, and red pepper with a ginger-soy glaze, finished with diced avocados, green onions, and sesame seeds.
Crab Trap
If you’re seeking one of the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach FL, look no further than the Crab Trap. Start your meal with Filet Mignon Sliders, topped with applewood bacon jam, crumbled blue cheese, and baby arugula on a toasted bun. For the main course, indulge in the Lobster Stuffed Flounder, served with green pea risotto, saffron lobster cream, roasted asparagus, sauteed spinach, and grilled tomato. Finish off your dining experience with the decadent Candied Sweet Potato Crème Brulee, topped with whipped cream and crushed candied pecans.
Plan Your Visit
Ready to try these incredible Amelia Island seafood restaurants for yourself? Browse our full inventory of Amelia Island rentals to get started!
Timoti’s Seafood Shak
Timoti’s Seafood Shak is a beloved local spot that offers fresh and flavorful seafood dishes. Begin your meal with their Chopped Salad box, featuring fresh greens topped with beets, carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, toasted pecans, feta, figs, croutons, and fig vinaigrette. Follow it up with their signature Fish Sandwich, available blackened, grilled, or fried, and served with romaine, tomato, and T’s Bam-Bam sauce on a toasted bun. This Fernandina Beach location is perfect for those craving a casual yet satisfying seafood meal.
Down Under Restaurant
Down Under Restaurant is a unique culinary gem with an ambiance that showcases marine wildlife, including birds, alligators, manatees, sea otters, dolphins, sea turtles, and more. Originally the site of a fish camp, Down Under Restaurant has been serving customers since 1982 and its incredible riverfront location serves as the perfect backdrop for an unforgettable dining experience. As you enjoy a little piece of Fernandina’s history, start your meal with the Jalapeno Poppers, stuffed with cream cheese and served with a raspberry soy dipping sauce. For the entree, try the Grouper Meuniere, an 8-10 oz grouper coated in flour and pan-fried with capers, lemon juice, white wine, garlic, butter, and fresh herbs. The unique location and delectable food make this a must-visit restaurant.
Explore Our Amelia Island Rentals
While you savor the delectable offerings of Fernandina Beach seafood restaurants, extend your stay by exploring various Amelia Island condo rentals. These cozy accommodations provide the perfect escape as you discover the best seafood restaurants in Fernandina Beach FL. Whether you prefer beachfront properties or quaint inland stays, our condo rentals in Amelia Island offer the ideal base for your culinary adventures. Wake up to stunning views of the beach, relax on your private balcony, and immerse yourself in the island’s beauty and tranquility. Book with us today for the ultimate Amelia Island vacation experience!